Last updated: Dec 2025
Most “best alternatives” lists don’t help because they skip the real problem:
You don’t need “the best app.” You need the best app for your style.
This scorecard gives you a clear, repeatable way to evaluate any Character.AI alternative in 10 minutes — no guessing, no hype.
TL;DR
- Run a 5-prompt test (copy/paste below).
- Score each platform across 8 categories.
- Pick the top scorer — and stop wasting weekends on “almost good” bots.
🎁 Want to test Storychat right now? Sign up via this link to get 500 SP automatically.
Step 1) The 5-prompt test (copy/paste)
Use these exact prompts on any platform you’re testing. Don’t improvise — consistency makes the score meaningful.
Prompt A — Voice Lock
Copy/paste: “Reply in your signature voice. No generic advice. Stay emotionally specific and in-character.”
Prompt B — Scene Anchor
Copy/paste: “Scene anchor: rooftop, midnight, raining. You’re tense but controlled. Continue the scene without breaking tone.”
Prompt C — Memory Pin
Copy/paste: “Remember this detail: the key is under the third loose floorboard. Don’t repeat it now.”
Chat about anything else for 6–8 messages, then ask:
Follow-up: “Where did we hide the key?”
Prompt D — Anti-Generic Constraint
Copy/paste: “No summaries. No disclaimers. No meta talk. Immersive roleplay only.”
Prompt E — Continuity Recap
Copy/paste: “Recap what just happened in 3 bullets (in-character), then continue the scene.”
Step 2) Scorecard (rate 0–5)
Score each category from 0 to 5. Then add your total. The highest score wins.
1) Voice Consistency (0–5)
Does the character keep the same vibe across prompts — or drift into bland chatbot mode?
2) Memory & Recall (0–5)
Can it recall a small pinned fact after 6–10 turns without guessing?
3) Scene Discipline (0–5)
Does it keep location, mood, and tension stable? Or drop the scene instantly?
4) Control & Constraints (0–5)
When you ask “no advice / no meta,” does it actually comply reliably?
5) Persona Tooling (0–5)
Can you define voice, boundaries, and rules cleanly (without fighting the UI)?
6) Discovery (0–5)
Can you find great characters easily — or do you need luck?
7) Creator Features (0–5)
Does the platform help creators ship better content (sharing, stories, visuals, etc.)?
8) Speed & Reliability (0–5)
Does it respond fast, stay stable, and feel usable daily?
Step 3) Switching checklist (so you don’t lose your best character)
If you’re migrating from Character.AI, don’t paste your entire chat history. That often makes outputs vague.
Instead, move only:
- Voice: how they speak (tone, rhythm, tension)
- Canon: 3 non-negotiable facts (relationship, rule, current conflict)
- Boundary: one personality “anchor” (prevents drift)
Then run the 5-prompt test again.
Why Storychat scores well for many ex-Character.AI users
Storychat is built around two things many C.ai users care about:
- Longer continuity for story-like chats
- Discovery + shareability so great characters don’t stay hidden
Try Storychat with 500 SP (free)
Run the same 10-minute scorecard on Storychat and compare results honestly.
Get 500 SP automatically via the blog link:
FAQ
Is this only about NSFW?
No. This scorecard is about story quality: voice, continuity, and control.
What score means “switch now”?
If your current platform scores under 20/40 in repeated tests, you’ll likely keep feeling the same frustration.
What’s the most important category?
For long roleplay: Voice Consistency + Memory + Scene Discipline.
